Sunday, January 29, 2012

Some Like It Digital: The Rise of Portfolios in the K-12 Classroom

Modernized, Not Standardized, Assessments
            In an age where academic assessment is often equated to standardized multiple-choice tests, personal portfolios offer a window into an individual student’s progress. To keep up with the times and reduce paperwork, academic portfolios have gone digital. A digital portfolio is a purposeful electronic collection of students’ work that is characterized by “a strong vision of content”.  

Types of Portfolios

  • Working Portfolio: includes projects of assignments the student is currently working on or has recently completed
  • Display Portfolio: contains samples of the student’s best work
  • Assessment Portfolio: presents work that demonstrates that the student has met specific learning goals
Moving Through Each Stage
The working portfolio is the first type of portfolio to be created as students begin to gather items from assignments and projects. As items accumulate in their portfolios, students are able to be more selective about what items to keep that best displays their efforts and work. The final stage of building a portfolio involves selecting examples of a student’s best work to present for assessment. The assessment portfolio also contains a reflection or explanation of how the included works are significant and show they meet learning goals.

Five Steps of Digital Portfolio Development
1.     Selection: developing criteria for items to be included in the portfolio
2.     Collection: gathering of items based on the purpose of the portfolio, audience, and future use
3.     Reflection: statements that describe the significance of each work and how it relates to the collection as a whole
4.     Direction: a review of the reflections that considers future learning goals
5.     Connection: the creation of hypertext links and publication, providing opportunity for feedback

Three Cheers for Digital Portfolios
The unique aspect of having a digital portfolio is the adaptability to emphasize specific goals and access to other resources via hyperlinks.  Students may customize their portfolios by use of hyperlinks to reinforce certain ideas or concepts that relate to their area of focus, including state standards. That goes without saying, digital portfolios keep much better than a single paper-based copy.


Portfolios At Any Age!
            For the particularly computer-savvy younger generations, digital portfolios can be created using age-appropriate web tools. With guidance and instruction from a teacher, students in elementary school can be coached to create their own portfolios. Although digital portfolios are more common in higher education than K-12 classrooms, they are rapidly gaining popularity with the influx of technology being introduced into various school districts. The access to computers and Internet is becoming more commonplace in K-12 education, thus increasing the possibilities for expression of content and skill mastery – in digital!

Mind the Gap
            Thinking about introducing digital portfolios in your classroom? Approach with caution. Resist the urge to turn a digital portfolio into a digital scrapbook. The temptation lies in the customizable nature of anything digital. The difference between a digital portfolio and a digital scrapbook lies in the reflection stage – each item presented in the portfolio must represent achievement or mastery of a particular learning goal or standard. Scrapbooks are more a less a collection that may have a theme or focus, but depend more heavily on the inclusion of multimedia or other visual aspects to make it appealing.   

Guidelines for Developing Digital Portfolios
            So how does a teacher begin to implement the use of digital portfolios in the classroom anyway?

  • Be realistic in design and expectations – portfolios are not scrapbooks!
  • Use relevant models – what does a good portfolio look like?
  • Instill a sense of ownership in students creating portfolios – an engaged student is a learning student.
  • Be clear with implementation instructions – do students know how and why they are creating a portfolio of their work?
  • Be selective –establish a particular design or strategy for adding items to the portfolio
  • Allow for growth and improvement – portfolios can change as students and their work changes.
  • Incorporate assessment – this should be done for each stage or phase of portfolio creation.
Original article from Education World

2 comments:

  1. Ms. Martin,
    I love the idea of Digital Portfolios. Considering you, too, are going into the secondary education field (English) I think it is only fitting that you blog about an up and coming resource that can be used when we teach. I have a few concerns though. One is that students could take too long on creating a digital portfolio. I feel that teachers should be aware of how they construct classroom time and free time around creating the portfolio. Students will have to have been already well versed in computer technology to be able to complete the tasks required and they will have the responsibility of managing their own time when not in the classroom.
    With that being said, I think that this can be easily helped with a thorough rubric and the idea that this would be a summative assessment. I think that if used as a summative assessment, it can be a good testament to what students have learned throughout the year. I am excited to use such opportunities in the future. I think that this would be something beneficial for students in exploring the multifaceted points of views an in-class-text can provide while still giving them the freedom to construct and prove what they have learned. How exciting! Thank you for your blog post.
    Ms. Watkins

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Another quick passing thought: This would also be a great way to incorporate the state and national standards for teaching technology to classrooms. http://www.doe.virginia.gov/testing/sol/standards_docs/computer_technology/index.shtml

      Delete